What the show runners did was create a television program could be sophisticated and dark and smart without being on a premium channel, without playing to people's baser desires, and without making the show sensationalistic or even terribly personal. The show's dynamic comes after the titillating action has occurred. There are no high speed chases, no shots of a grotesque and mutilated corpse for shock value, and no murders on screen. We come in after the homicide has taken place and our detectives are called on the scene, and the show is all the better for it. The show also does something incredible: it posts realistic outputs in terms of how many homicides the detectives solve. On a show like House or Bones, the audience has an expectation that the disease would be found or the murderer would be apprehended, because House and Bones are the best in their respective fields. But Law & Order's solved crime rates are incredible; as are CSI's, Cold Case, and numerous other cop shows. And I refuse to believe that every single detective in every department spanning Law & Order's franchise is the premiere in their field. Homicide had excellent detectives, those who were the best of the best, and it had a white board: unsolved homicides in red, solved in black. And the ratio between the two wasn't huge. Most detectives had as many or more red cases as they did black. And many cases we were introduced to in the course of the show went on unsolved, because that is the true way of a Homicide department.
Homicide's characters were not PC; they weren't always likable or nice or easy to route for. They were at times racist, sexist, wrong, or just plain assholic. But the thing we see day in and day out is how normalized their job really is to them. At one point, a character tells the husband of a victim that every detective remembers his first homicide, but no one remembers their 40th, or 50th. Because of that, the episodes themselves play more mundanely than one would ever expect a crime show's episodes to be. And this type of show is the precursor to Sports Night, or The West Wing -shows that also concentrated almost solely on characters at their jobs who do their jobs well and whose personal lives are left on the periphery of the screen even as we learn details about them. And because the show is so well-written, because it stands up against the shows of today in its intensity and its maturity and its ability to enthrall the audience, it doesn't matter that its first episode aired 15 years ago and its last original appearance on television was 8 years ago. Everyone interested in quality television should be prepared to watch it, and be amazed by it.